The Best Rowing Machine Reddit

Reddit’s fitness communities are a goldmine for honest, real-world feedback on home gym equipment, and rowing machines are no exception.

Whether you’re browsing r/Rowing, r/HomeGym, or r/Fitness, you’ll find thousands of threads debating the best rowing machine for every budget and space.

To cut through the noise, we’ve compiled a research-driven roundup of the top-rated models that consistently earn praise from both experts and verified buyers.

Our team analyzed specifications, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback to score each machine on our 0, 10 BP Score. Below, you’ll find the rowing machines that Reddit users most frequently recommend, backed by data, not hype.

From the gold-standard Concept2 RowErg to budget-friendly magnetic rowers, our list covers air, water, and magnetic resistance types to suit different training goals and room sizes. We’ve also included buying tips to help you decide which features matter most.

Scroll down to see our top picks, or jump straight to the buying guide for detailed advice.

Best Rowing Machine Reddit Buying Guide

Resistance Type: Air, Magnetic, or Water?

The type of resistance defines the feel and intensity of your workout. Air rowers, like the Concept2 RowErg, use a fan that creates resistance proportional to your effort, the harder you pull, the more resistance you feel.

This mimics on-water rowing and is favored by serious athletes and CrossFit enthusiasts. Magnetic rowers use a flywheel and magnets to provide smooth, quiet resistance that can be adjusted with a dial or remote.

They’re ideal for apartment dwellers or anyone who wants a whisper-quiet workout. Water rowers use a tank of water to simulate the sensation of sculling; the swoosh sound adds to the immersive experience.

Each type has its advocates on Reddit: air for performance tracking, magnetic for low noise, and water for aesthetics and feel.

Your choice should align with your primary use case. If you plan to follow structured training programs or compete in virtual challenges, an air rower with a PM5 monitor (like the Concept2) is the standard.

For casual fitness and TV-watching, a magnetic rower offers quiet operation and easy storage. Water rowers are a middle ground that looks great in a living room but may require more maintenance.

For a deeper dive into resistance types, check out our guide to air rowing machines.

Monitor and Connectivity

A good monitor tracks essential metrics like stroke rate, distance, calories, and split time (time per 500m). The gold standard is Concept2’s PM5, which syncs via Bluetooth to apps like ErgData, Strava, and Zwift.

Many magnetic rowers now offer app connectivity through Bluetooth or ANT+, allowing you to follow guided workouts or race against others. Budget models may have basic LCD screens that show time and count, while premium options include full-color touchscreens.

Reddit users often emphasize that a reliable monitor with app integration keeps workouts engaging and helps track progress over time.

When evaluating monitors, check if the rower is compatible with popular apps like Kinomap, iFIT, or Asensei. Some machines, like the YOSUDA water rower, include a dedicated Bluetooth app for training programs.

If you’re data-driven, prioritize a rower with a PM5 or equivalent. For a broader look at connected options, see our connected rowing machine guide.

Build Quality and Durability

Rowing machines endure repetitive, high-force strokes, so a sturdy frame is non-negotiable. Look for steel or aluminum frames with a weight capacity that exceeds your body weight by at least 50 lbs.

The Concept2 RowErg is legendary for its durability, many Reddit users report machines still going strong after a decade. Magnetic rowers like the Sunny Health & Fitness model offer dual-rail designs that reduce wobble.

Water rowers often use beechwood or birch wood frames that are both strong and attractive. Check the warranty: Concept2 offers 2 years on the frame and 5 years on the monitor, while budget brands may offer only 1 year.

For more on long-lasting options, read our durable rowing machine recommendations.

Also consider the seat and rail. A contoured, padded seat on a smooth-gliding rail reduces discomfort during long sessions. Some cheaper rowers have narrow or rough rails that can cause friction.

Verified buyer feedback often highlights seat comfort as a dealbreaker, so prioritize models with positive reviews on this front.

Space and Storage

Rowing machines can be bulky, but many models now fold vertically or split into two pieces for easy storage. The YOSUDA water rower folds upright and has a small footprint, making it a favorite for apartments.

The Concept2 RowErg separates into two halves and can be leaned against a wall. Magnetic rowers like the Flesar and Dripex often have a compact design and wheels for rolling away.

Before buying, measure your ceiling height: folding upright requires about 6, 7 feet of clearance. If space is tight, consider a compact rowing machine that fits under a bed or in a closet.

Storage convenience also affects how often you’ll use the machine. A rower that’s easy to stow and retrieve encourages consistent workouts. Reddit threads are full of tips on vertical storage racks and wall mounts for rowers.

If you plan to move the machine frequently, look for models with transport wheels and a lightweight frame (under 70 lbs).

Budget Considerations

Rowing machine prices range from under $200 to over $1,000. The best value often sits in the $200, $500 range, where you can find magnetic rowers with app connectivity and decent build quality.

Budget models like the Wenoker or Dripex offer solid performance for beginners, while the Sunny Health & Fitness smart rower provides a good balance of features and price.

At the premium end, the Concept2 RowErg costs around $990 but is considered a lifetime investment by many Reddit users. Water rowers like the YOSUDA fall in the mid-range and offer a unique aesthetic.

For the most bang for your buck, see our economical rowing machine picks.

Don’t overlook used options. Concept2 rowers hold their value and are frequently sold on Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace. Reddit’s r/Rowing and r/HomeGym have dedicated threads for buying and selling.

If you’re on a tight budget, a used Concept2 can outperform many new budget rowers.

Why You Should Trust Us

BestProducts is an independent review site that evaluates products through comprehensive research, not physical product trials.

Each rowing machine is scored on our 0, 10 BP Score based on a consistent set of criteria: specifications, expert review consensus, verified buyer feedback, and published data from reputable sources.

We do not conduct our own product trials; our evaluations are grounded in research, published data, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback.

Our team regularly monitors Reddit discussions, professional reviews, and user forums to ensure our recommendations reflect real-world experiences.

We are transparent about our affiliate relationships: if you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not influence our rankings or opinions.

For more on our methodology, you can explore our home gym category or read about how we score products in our reviewed rowing machine guide.

Final Thoughts

After analyzing dozens of models and cross-referencing Reddit consensus with expert reviews, here are our top recommendations:

• Best Overall: Concept2 RowErg Indoor Rowing Machine with PM5 Monitor, The undisputed king of rowing machines, beloved by Reddit for its durability, accurate performance tracking, and community support. Its BP Score reflects near-perfect ratings across all criteria.
• Best Budget Pick: Sunny Health & Fitness Smart Magnetic Rower, Offers exceptional value with a quiet magnetic resistance system and Bluetooth connectivity at a price that won’t break the bank. Highly rated by budget-conscious Redditors.
• Best for Small Spaces: YOSUDA Water Rowing Machine (Foldable Wooden), Combines the smooth feel of water resistance with a foldable design that saves floor space. Its wooden frame adds a touch of elegance to any room.
• Best Quiet Option: Flesar Magnetic Rowing Machine, Ideal for apartment dwellers, this magnetic rower operates almost silently while offering 16 levels of resistance and app support.

No matter your budget or fitness level, one of these rowing machines will help you build endurance and strength at home. For additional options, browse our full rowing machines category or check out our home rowing machine guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of rowing machine do Reddit users recommend most?

Air rowers, particularly the Concept2 RowErg, are the most frequently recommended on Reddit. Users praise its reliability, accurate performance data, and the thriving community around it. It’s the go-to choice for serious training and competitive rowing.

However, magnetic and water rowers are also popular for home use due to their quieter operation and lower cost.

Is a water rower better than a magnetic rower?

It depends on your priorities. Water rowers provide a more realistic rowing feel with a soothing water sound, but they require occasional maintenance (adding water purification tablets) and are heavier to move.

Magnetic rowers are quieter, lighter, and often cheaper, but the resistance can feel less natural. Reddit users often suggest trying both in a store before deciding. For a detailed comparison, see our hydro rowing machine guide.

How much should I spend on a rowing machine for home use?

For a quality machine that will last, expect to spend at least $200, 300. Budget models under $200 can work for light use but may lack durability and accurate metrics.

The sweet spot for most home users is $300, 600, where you get magnetic or water resistance with app connectivity. The Concept2 at $990 is a premium investment but holds its value and is often considered a buy-it-for-life purchase.

Reddit’s consensus: spend as much as you can afford on a rower with good build quality and a strong warranty.

Can I use a rowing machine for weight loss?

Absolutely. Rowing is a full-body, low-impact exercise that burns calories efficiently. A 155-pound person can burn around 250, 300 calories in 30 minutes of moderate rowing. Combined with a healthy diet, regular rowing sessions can support weight loss.

Many Reddit users share success stories of losing weight using a rower as their primary cardio machine. To maximize results, vary your intensity and incorporate interval training.

What is the best rowing machine for tall or heavy users?

The Concept2 RowErg accommodates users up to 6’5″ with its long rail and adjustable footrests. For heavier users, look for a weight capacity of at least 350 lbs.

The YOSUDA water rower supports up to 400 lbs, and the Dripex magnetic rower handles 360 lbs. Always check the rail length and seat height if you’re tall. Reddit threads often recommend the Concept2 for its adjustable ergonomics and robust construction.

For more options, see our quality rowing machine guide.

How do I maintain a rowing machine?

Maintenance varies by type. For air rowers, vacuum the fan housing occasionally and lubricate the chain every 50 hours of use. Magnetic rowers require little maintenance, just wipe down the rails and seat after each workout.

Water rowers need a water purification tablet every few months to prevent algae growth, and the tank should be topped off with distilled water. Always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines.

Reddit users recommend checking the foldable rowing machine guide for storage tips that also help preserve the machine.

About the author