The Best Refrigerator Without Ice Maker

If you have been shopping for a new refrigerator, you may have noticed that many models come with a built-in ice maker.

While convenient, these ice makers are one of the most common points of failure, with repair costs often running into hundreds of dollars.

An increasing number of homeowners are choosing a refrigerator without ice maker and instead pairing it with a dedicated standalone ice machine.

This approach not only eliminates a major source of breakdowns but also gives you more usable freezer space and the flexibility to produce ice on demand.

In this guide, we have evaluated the top standalone ice makers on the market, scoring each on our 0-to-10 BP Score based on their specifications, expert consensus, and verified buyer feedback.

Whether you need a compact countertop model for a small kitchen or a high-capacity undercounter machine for entertaining, our picks will help you find the perfect solution.

Below you will find our curated selection of the best ice makers to pair with a refrigerator that lacks a built-in dispenser. Click through to see full reviews, pros and cons, and the latest prices.

Best Refrigerator Without Ice Maker Buying Guide

Type and Placement

Standalone ice makers come in three main form factors: countertop, undercounter, and portable. Countertop models are compact and easy to place on a kitchen counter; they are ideal for small households or occasional use.

Undercounter units are built into cabinetry and offer higher ice production, making them suitable for larger families or home bars. Portable ice makers are lightweight and often rechargeable, perfect for camping, RVs, or tailgating.

Consider your available space and how much ice you need daily to choose the right type.

If you plan to install an undercounter ice maker, verify the dimensions and clearance requirements. Some models need ventilation space, while others are freestanding. For countertop models, ensure you have a stable, level surface near an electrical outlet.

For portability, check the weight and handle design.

Ice Production Rate and Storage Capacity

Ice production is measured in pounds per 24 hours. Entry-level machines produce around 26 pounds per day, which is sufficient for a family of four. High-capacity undercounter units can churn out 100 pounds or more.

Also consider the integrated storage bin; a larger bin means fewer trips to empty the ice into a freezer. If you entertain frequently, look for models with at least a 30-pound storage capacity.

Keep in mind that actual production depends on ambient temperature and water temperature. Most manufacturers’ ratings are based on 70°F room temperature and 50°F water. If your kitchen is warmer or your water is warmer, output may be slightly lower.

Ice Shape and Size Options

Different ice makers produce different shapes: bullet, cube, nugget, or gourmet. Bullet ice is common in compact countertop models and tends to be softer and more chewable.

Nugget ice (like Sonic ice) is popular for its chewiness but is less common in standalone machines. Cube ice is denser and melts slower, ideal for cocktails.

Some units offer adjustable ice thickness or size settings, letting you customize from small to large cubes.

If you have a specific use in mind, like iced coffee or whiskey on the rocks, choose the ice shape accordingly. For general household use, bullet ice is fine; for premium drinks, look for clear cube ice makers.

Ease of Use and Maintenance

Most modern ice makers feature simple control panels with buttons for power, select size, and self-cleaning cycles. Self-cleaning functions are a major time-saver, as they flush out mineral buildup and keep the ice tasting fresh.

Also check how easy it is to remove the ice basket and clean the interior. Models with a transparent window let you monitor ice level without opening the door, minimizing warm air intrusion.

Noise level varies by model. Countertop units are generally quieter than undercounter compressors. Look for noise ratings around 35 to 45 decibels for a peaceful kitchen environment. If you plan to place the ice maker in a living area or open-plan space, prioritize low-noise models.

Build Quality and Warranty

Stainless steel construction is more durable and easier to clean than plastic. Many models also feature a stainless steel exterior that resists fingerprints.

Check the warranty: most budget models offer 1 year, while premium brands may offer 2 to 5 years on the compressor. Reading verified buyer feedback can reveal common issues like leaks or pump failures.

For added peace of mind, consider a brand with a strong reputation for customer support, such as Frigidaire or EUHOMY.

If you plan to run the ice maker continuously, a robust compressor and insulation are important. Some units are designed for commercial use and have a higher duty cycle. For home use, a well-reviewed consumer model will suffice.

Special Features

Additional features can enhance convenience: automatic shut-off when the bin is full, indicator lights for water refill, programmable timers, and compatibility with countertop ice makers that include a scoop. Some models offer dual ice sizes or even a water dispenser.

Wi-Fi connectivity is rare but available on a few premium units. When evaluating features, consider what you actually need, extra bells and whistles may increase cost without adding value.

For those who want a complete solution without a built-in ice maker, pairing a high-quality standalone ice maker with a large chest freezer can provide ample ice storage and freezer space. Also explore our freezers category for more ideas.

Why You Should Trust Us

At BestProducts, we evaluate each product using our proprietary BP Score (0 to 10). Our methodology relies on comprehensive research: we analyze specifications, compile expert review consensus from multiple sources, aggregate verified buyer feedback, and cross-check published data.

We do not conduct our own product trials; our evaluations are grounded in research, published data, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback.

This systematic approach ensures our recommendations are objective and consistently updated as new models release and data evolves.

We are an independent publication and accept no payment from manufacturers for favorable reviews. Our affiliate partnerships (e.g., Amazon Associates) allow us to earn a small commission on qualifying purchases, but this does not influence our assessments.

Each product is scored solely on its merits.

Final Thoughts

Choosing a refrigerator without ice maker and adding a dedicated ice machine gives you the best of both worlds: a more reliable cooling appliance and flexible ice production. Based on our analysis, here are our top picks:

Best Overall: EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker Machine, With the top BP Score among our picks (9.9/10), this compact countertop model produces bullet ice in just 6 minutes, has a convenient auto-cleaning cycle, and offers excellent value at a budget-friendly price point.

It is perfect for small households or as a secondary ice source.

Best for High Capacity: EUHOMY Commercial Ice Maker Machine, For larger families or entertaining, this undercounter unit produces 100 pounds of ice per day and stores 33 pounds. Its stainless steel build and freestanding design make it a reliable workhorse, scoring 9.5/10.

Best Budget Pick: FRIGIDAIRE Retro Compact Ice Maker, Available in multiple colors, this 26 lb/day model brings retro style and dependable performance without breaking the bank. Its 9.5/10 BP Score reflects strong user satisfaction and durability.

Best for Commercial Use: CuisinAid Commercial Ice Maker Machine, With 90 lbs daily production and six ice thickness settings, this undercounter machine is ideal for cafes, bars, or serious home entertainers. It scores 9.5/10 for its adjustability and sturdy construction.

To further explore your options, check out our appliances hub for more guides on kitchen essentials.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a standalone ice maker with any refrigerator?

Yes. Standalone ice makers are independent appliances that require only an electrical outlet and a water source. They can be placed on a countertop, under a cabinet, or on a cart.

You can use them alongside a refrigerator without ice maker or with any other fridge. Just ensure you have space for the machine and easy access to fill the water reservoir or connect a water line (for undercounter models).

How much ice do I need per day?

A general guideline: a family of four uses about 25, 30 pounds of ice per week under normal conditions.

If you entertain guests regularly or use a lot of ice for drinks and coolers, aim for a machine that produces at least 26, 50 pounds per day. For occasional use, a small countertop model (26 lbs/day) is sufficient.

Is it cheaper to buy a refrigerator without an ice maker and a separate ice machine?

Often, yes. A refrigerator without ice maker typically costs less than its equivalent with a built-in ice maker. Plus, if the standalone ice maker fails, you replace only that unit, not the whole refrigerator.

Over the long term, repair and replacement costs are lower. Many families find the combination more economical and reliable.

Do standalone ice makers require a permanent water line?

Only undercounter models typically require a direct water connection. Countertop and portable ice makers have a built-in water tank that you refill manually. Some portable models can also be connected to a water supply via a quick-connect fitting. Check the specifications before purchase.

How do I clean my ice maker?

Most modern ice makers have a self-cleaning cycle that circulates a cleaning solution (often vinegar or a commercial cleaner) through the system. You can also manually scrub the interior and ice basket with mild detergent and rinse thoroughly.

Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to keep ice tasting fresh and prevent mold or scale buildup. Cleaning every 2, 4 weeks is recommended.

Can I leave an ice maker on all the time?

Yes, most standalone ice makers are designed for continuous operation. They have an automatic shut-off when the bin is full and will stop producing ice until ice is removed.

However, if you are not using ice for several days, it is advisable to empty and dry the machine to prevent stagnant water and odors. For portable models, unplugging when not in use saves energy.

For more tips on maintaining kitchen appliances, see our guide on best undercounter dishwashers or dishwasher cleaner.

About the author