The Best Countertop Arby’s Ice Maker

If you’ve ever craved the soft, chewable nugget ice that makes drinks at fast-food chains so satisfying, you know that standard ice cubes from your freezer just don’t cut it.

A dedicated countertop ice maker delivers fresh, high-quality ice on demand, perfect for cocktails, iced coffee, or just keeping your water crisp. But with so many models on the market, finding the right one can be overwhelming.

That’s where we come in.

At BestProducts, we’ve conducted comprehensive research, analyzing specifications, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback, to identify the best countertop ice makers available in 2026.

Our picks are scored on a consistent 0, 10 BP Score, ensuring you get an unbiased recommendation you can trust. Below, you’ll find our top-rated machines, each chosen for its ice quality, speed, ease of use, and overall value.

Countertop Ice Maker Buying Guide

Ice Type and Quality

The most important factor is the shape and texture of ice produced. Bullet-shaped ice is common in countertop machines and freezes quickly, while nugget (or “sonic”) ice is soft, chewable, and ideal for blended drinks or sodas.

Some models also offer crescent or cube shapes. If you’re after the Arby’s-style nugget ice, look for machines specifically labeled as nugget ice makers, they use a different freezing mechanism that creates that iconic texture.

For a deeper dive into this category, check out our dedicated guide to the best nugget ice makers.

Ice quality also depends on how quickly the machine cycles. Most models produce ice in 6, 15 minutes, but the first batch may take longer. Machines with self-cleaning functions help maintain ice purity and prevent odors, which is especially important if you use the machine daily.

Production Speed and Capacity

Daily yield is measured in pounds per 24 hours. Entry-level machines produce around 26, 28 lbs, while larger units can churn out 40, 45 lbs. For a home bar or frequent entertaining, a higher capacity is worth the investment.

However, don’t confuse daily yield with storage, most countertop models only hold a few pounds at a time, so you’ll need to transfer ice to a freezer if you need a large supply.

For portable use, a compact machine with a carry handle is ideal, our roundup of portable ice makers can help you find the right fit.

Speed is also critical: many machines make 9 cubes in as little as 6 minutes. But note that the first batch often takes longer because the internal components need to cool down. Some models have a “quick ice” mode that accelerates the process.

Size and Portability

Countertop ice makers come in various footprints. Measure your available space carefully, some models are nearly 17 inches tall and deep.

If you plan to move the machine between kitchen, RV, or campsite, look for a model with a built-in handle and a lightweight design (under 20 lbs).

Compact options like the best mini ice makers are great for small counters or dorm rooms. Also consider the water reservoir: machines with a removable tank are easier to fill and clean.

For semi-permanent installation, some machines allow direct water line connection, but most are self-contained with a manual fill. If you hate refilling, a larger tank (2+ liters) reduces frequency.

Ease of Cleaning and Maintenance

Regular cleaning is essential to prevent mold and scale buildup. Many modern ice makers include a self-cleaning cycle that flushes the system with vinegar or a cleaning solution. Models with removable ice baskets and scoops are easier to maintain.

Some units also have a drain plug for easy water removal. For long-term reliability, choose a machine with stainless steel interior components rather than plastic. Our guide to home ice makers covers more tips on upkeep.

Also check the warranty, most offer 12 months, but some brands extend to 24 or 36 months for added peace of mind.

Noise Level

Countertop ice makers produce a constant hum from the compressor and fan, plus the sound of ice dropping into the bin.

Noise levels vary widely, some models operate around 40 dB (quiet as a library), while others can reach 50 dB or more.

If you plan to use the machine in a bedroom, office, or while watching TV, look for units specifically marketed as quiet. User reviews often mention noise, so it’s worth scanning those comments.

For a quieter alternative, consider a under-counter ice maker that’s built into cabinetry and better insulated.

Additional Features

Modern ice makers come with handy extras: LED displays that show remaining time and water level, timer functions to schedule ice production, and smart features like app control.

Some machines offer two ice cube sizes (small and large) to suit different drinks. If you entertain often, a model with a transparent window lets you monitor ice level without opening the lid.

For cocktail enthusiasts, a specialized cocktail ice maker might offer larger cubes that melt slowly.

Portable machines with carrying handles and lightweight builds are ideal for camping or tailgating. Also consider the warranty and customer support reputation of the brand, verified buyer feedback is a great resource for that.

Why You Should Trust Us

BestProducts is an independent review site that evaluates products through a rigorous, consistent methodology.

Each product in this guide has been assigned a BP Score on a scale of 0 to 10 based on our analysis of published specifications, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback.

We do not conduct our own product trials; our evaluations are grounded in research, published data, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback. Our goal is to provide you with unbiased, data-driven recommendations you can rely on.

We have no financial ties to any manufacturer or retailer, our affiliate relationships are clearly disclosed and never influence our scores or selections. For more on our process, see our full countertop ice maker methodology.

Final Thoughts

After evaluating dozens of models, these are the countertop ice makers that earned our highest BP Scores. Whether you prioritize speed, nugget ice, or budget-friendly value, there’s a top pick for you:

• Best Overall: EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker Machine with Handle, This well-rounded model combines fast 6-minute ice, a 26-lb daily yield, and auto-cleaning convenience, earning it the top spot in our rankings for its balance of performance and affordability.
• Best Nugget Ice Maker: EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop, If you crave soft, chewable nugget ice, this 34-lb/day machine delivers with a 6-minute first batch and a removable top cover for easy cleaning.
• Best Value: Sweetcrispy Countertop Ice Maker, At under $50, this portable machine offers 9 cubes in 6 minutes and a 26.5-lb daily capacity, making it an unbeatable budget pick for occasional use.
• Best for Large Capacity: Silonn Ice Makers Countertop, 44lbs Per Day, With dual water fill options and a generous daily yield, this stainless steel machine is perfect for parties and high-volume households.
• Most Portable: DUMOS Countertop Ice Maker with Handle, Lightweight, compact, and available in fun colors, this model is ideal for RVs, camping, or small kitchens where space is tight.

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of ice does a countertop ice maker produce?

Most countertop models produce bullet-shaped or nugget ice. Bullet ice is clear and hard, while nugget ice is soft, chewable, and porous, ideal for absorbing flavors in cocktails or sodas. Some machines offer both small and large bullet sizes.

For nugget ice, look for models specifically labeled as nugget ice makers. Learn more in our pebble ice maker guide.

How long does it take to make ice?

Most machines produce the first batch in 6, 15 minutes, though the initial cycle may be longer while the unit cools down. Subsequent batches are faster.

Daily yield ranges from 26 to 45 lbs, but the ice basket holds only a few pounds at a time, so you’ll need to store excess ice in a freezer.

Do countertop ice makers need a water line?

No, most are self-contained with a removable water reservoir that you fill manually. This makes them portable and easy to set up anywhere with an electrical outlet.

Some high-end models offer a direct water line option, but the vast majority are manual fill. For more details, see our tabletop ice maker overview.

How do I clean my ice maker?

Many models have a self-cleaning cycle that uses a vinegar or citric acid solution. You can also manually clean the reservoir, ice basket, and scoop with warm soapy water. Descale every 1, 2 months to prevent mineral buildup.

For a step-by-step routine, check out our reviewed ice maker maintenance tips.

Are countertop ice makers noisy?

They produce a constant hum from the compressor and fan, plus occasional ice-dropping sounds. Quiet models operate around 40 dB, while louder ones reach 50 dB. If noise is a concern, check user reviews and look for machines with noise-reducing features.

Some compact units are designed to be whisper-quiet for office or bedroom use.

Can I use a countertop ice maker in an RV or while camping?

Absolutely, many models are designed with portability in mind, featuring carry handles, lightweight builds, and low power consumption. They can run on a standard household outlet or a generator.

Just ensure you have access to clean water and a way to drain the melted ice. Our best portable ice maker guide has specific recommendations for travel-friendly options.

About the author